help wanted - coloured contacts

It's that time of year again when I need to buy my contacts for cosplay. Needing some advice this year though for Hitsugaya and Squall. I was quite happy with the ones I used for Luke and so will be getting another pair of those.

Squall's though I'm thinking different ones because the ones last year bugged my eyes enough that I couldn't wear them and the color wasn't quite right.

coloured contacts is the site I used last year and so plan to use again.

Problem is they don't seem to have ones light enough for Toshiro. These are the ones I'm looking at:
classic aqua
emerald green

Well the second one is light enough but doesn't look natural at all...but I guess he is an anime character and all :)

For Squall I can't decide if I want blue, gray or a mix of both:
gray
sky blue
blue

Really though - just how blue are Squall's eyes?

So help please in deciding which to get *begs*